Mickey grapples with her guilt about her missing sister as questions mount surrounding the murdered women. Truman connects Mickey to a new suspect in the case and Mickey takes drastic measures to keep Thomas at his private school.

Mickey puts herself in danger while following up on the Dock lead. Mickey brings Thomas and Truman to her family's Thanksgiving and Paula's reaction to a new piece of evidence makes Mickey question everything.

Thomas's birthday party stirs up painful childhood memories for Mickey as tensions with Thomas's father boil over. An unexpected connection between the murder victims leads Mickey and Truman to pursue a new lead.

Mickey and Truman grow closer as they follow their new lead. A new victim complicates the case of the murdered women and raises the stakes in the hunt to find Kacey as Mickey reckons with her past choices.

An unlikely ambush leaves Mickey reeling and pauses Mickey's hunt for Kacey. Mickey and Truman's bond deepens as they spend holiday time together with Thomas. A Christmas revelation helps Mickey get closer to the truth about Kacey but drives a wedge between her and Gee.

As Mickey confronts the consequences of naming Paula, she reconnects with her family. A new development in the Jimmy Scanlon disappearance leads Mickey and Truman to surprising but familiar places.

Mickey makes a big mistake in her hunt for the killer, but her family helps to right the problem. A major showdown unites the neighborhood but turns deadly.